Home >> Scientific Study >>
PlasmoginePlasmogine
|
IN VIVO AND
IN VITRO ANTIMALARIAL ACTIVITIES OF PLASMOGINE
BY
Dr. Khin Maung Lwin MB,BS, Ph.D., DBA
And
Dr. Myint Oo MSc, DS, Ph.D.
FAME Pharmaceuticals Enterprise
Yangon, Myanmar |
ABSTRACT
Plasmogine,
a combined extract of Dichroa febrifuga, Artemisia annua
and Coptis teeta was tested for antimalarial
activity against Plasmodium berghei-mouse in vivo and
in vitro sensitivity against two isolates of Plasmodium
falciparum in culture using standard methods. It was observed that
in vivo ED90 was 100 mg/kg/day and minumum schizont
inhibition concentration (MIC) was found to be 50 ΅g/ml in vitro.
INTRODUCTION
Malaria remains the most important of
the tropical diseases. It is widespread throughout the tropical,
sub-tropical and many temperate regions of the world. Malaria is the
communicable disease which infects 270 million people worldwide (WHO,
1990) and claims 2.5 million lives annually. Malaria in humans is caused
by four species of protozoa parasites of genus Plasmodium, namely
P.falciparum, P.vivax, P.malariae and P.ovale.
Of the four species, P.falciparum
accounts for the most of the malarial infections in Africa and Southeast
Asia (including Myanmar). In Myanmar, 11% of the population (~ 4.98
millions) lives in no risk area but 89 %( ~ 40.29 millions in 1994 ) are
living in malaria endemic areas (VBDC Annual Report , 1994). According
to the National Health Programmes of Myanmar, malaria is the first
priority disease in terms of morbidity and mortality (National Health
Plan, 1996 ).
The existence of many genetic
variants in humans with innate resistance against malaria infection is
in example of evolutionary adaptation in the host brought about by an
endemic disease. While the human host is gradually adapting to the
malarial parasites over an evolutionary time scale of perhaps many
thousands of years, the parasites are also adapting to pressure put upon
them by the host over far shorter periods through the use of
antimalarial drugs. The relatively fast response of parasites to the
drug pressure is largely not understood, but probably relates to their
short life cycles and particular genomic structures which allow them to
undergo rapid changes.
The earliest description of drug
resistance dates to 1910 when resistance of P.falciparum to
quinine was reported from Brazil. Resistance to dihydrofolate reductase
(DHFR) inhibitors such as pyrimethamine was noted soon after their
introduction at the end of the second world war. Drug resistance become
a major problem with the emergency of resistance in P. falciparum
to the most potent and widely used synthetic antimalarial drug,
Chloroquine. The first evidence came almost simultaneously from South
American and Southeast Aisa in the late 1950s. The story is similar for
other antimalarials. For example, resistance to Mefloquine, a derivative
of 4 quinoline methnol, appeared only a few years after commercial
release.
At increased prevalence of multidrug
resistance strains of P. falciparum continue to reduce to
effectiveness of currently available antimalarial drugs. Nonetheless, in
the absence of effectiveness and practical preventive measures,
chemotherapy and chemoprophylaxis remain the only options for reducing
morbidity and mortality in many of the malaria-endemic countries. It is
obvious that P. falciparum in Myanmar has developed resistance to
all kinds of blood schizonticides; the longer the half life in the
circulation of the drug the sooner the parasite develops resistance to
the drug. Thus t1/2 of chloroquine, mefloquine, sulfadoxine
and pyrimethamine are about a month, 3 weeks, 200 hrs and 80 hrs
respectively; the shorter the t1/2 of the drug the longer
time the parasite takes to develop resistance. It is note worthy there
is still only occasional reports of resistance to quinine to whose t1/2
is 11-16 hours.
Therefore many scientists concentrate
their works on compounds of plant origin. One of the most poten
antimalarial isolated from Quinghaosu plant is artemisinine. The
therapeutic effectiveness of Quinghaosu and its derivatives (sesquiterpene
lactone peroxides )and their possible development in accordance with
international standards have continued to be the subject of intense
study. These naturally occurring peroxide compounds have been
extensively studied in China since 1970. Research on the hemisuccinyl
derivative, artesunate, and the methyl ether derivative, artemether
(focusing on the production methods), the standardization of
formulations and the development of methods for pharmacokinetic and
metabolic studies is being carried out.
As the antimalarial activity of the
Quinghaosu series of compounds appears todepend upon the 1,2,4 trixane
ring structure of the basic molecule a number of simpler compounds
containing this ring have been synthesized and are now being evaluated
for efficacy against P.falciparum. They do appear to have blood
schizontocidal activity.
Another promising and locally
available plant is Dichroa febrifuga ( Chang shan in Chinese, and
Yin Pyar in Myanmar ). This plant is cultivated and widely grown in Pyin
Oo Lwin area, Upper Myanmar. Some alkaloids have been isolated from the
root of this plant and proved to be the active principle for
antimalarial drug.
The third antiprotozoal herbal
medicine was observed in rhizome of Coptis teeta ( Golden
thread, Khan tauk myit in Myanmar ). Coptis teeta growsin icy
mountains of Kachin State, Myanmar and India and is used in Ayurvedic
medicine. The roots of the commercially important plant Coptis teeta
has been examined chemically, and found to contain the alkaloid,
berberine (identified by elemental analysis, U.V and I.R spectroscopy,
preparation of derivatives and by conversion to the tetrahydro-base) and
an unstable new alkaloid, m.p.181-182˚ in yields of 11.0 and 3.6 percent
respectively. Chinese herbalist also use preparations made from
Coptis teeta to relieve high fever and delirium. Modern scientific
research supports many of the traditional uses of coptis including anti-protozoal
effects.
Our study was conducted to test the
efficacy of FAMEs Plasmogine on in vivo rodent
malaria P.berghei system and in vitro sensitivity assays
with P. falciparum in the process of formulation of new
antimalarial drug with higher potency and lower resistancy.
MATERIALS AND
METHOD
In vivo Mouse Model
Plasmodium berghei - mouse
model system as described by Peters(1970 )9 was used to
screen the effect of the drugs. Both therapeutic and suppressive tests
were done to determine the efficacy of Plasmogine.
In vitro sensitivity assay
In vitro sensitivity assay of
Plasmogine was carried out with two isolates of Plasmodium
falciparum in microtitre plate containing RPMI1640 (LPLF) medium
using the methods described by WHO. The concentrations tested were 25,
50, 100, and 200 ΅g/ml. The desired concentrations of drug were obtained
by dissolving in the culture medium.
Extraction and purification of
Plasmogine :
The extraction and purification of
Plasmogine was done according to the standardized methods.
A capsule of Plasmogine
contains the total alkaloids of Dichroa febrifuga, Artemisia
annua, and Coptis teeta in the ratio of 1.20 gm, 0.06 gm, and
0.01 gm respectively.
Examination of acute and sub-acute
toxicity :
Acute and sub-acute toxicity tests
were carried out according to the methods described by Walter Reed Army
Research Institute, USA with some minor modification by Pharmacology
Research Division of Department of Medical Research (Lower Myanmar).
Three groups of ddy mice (
10 mice/each group ) were given oral Plasmogine 100, 200, 400,
800, 1,600 mg/kg/day respectively for four days. No sign of acute and
sub-acute toxicity were observed after eight weeks. Pathological
examinations of blood and organ tissues revealed no changes compared to
untreated controls.
Sources of
ingredients of Plasmogine:
Artemisia
annua (Quinghaosu), Dichroa febrifuga (Chan Shan , Yin-pyar)
were collected from FAMEs plantation site, Pyin Oo Lwin. Coptis
teeta (Khan tauk myit ) was locally purchased from Kachin state.
RESULTS
The effect of
Plasmogine on mice infected with Plasmodium berghei is
summarized in Table (1).
Table 1.The effects of oral
Plasmogine100mg/kgon the mice infectedwith P. berghei (At
day 6 after infection).
| |
Group |
| |
A |
B |
C |
| Number of
mice |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| Mean
Parasitaemia (at day 6) |
44.24 |
2.16% |
0.02 |
| Standard
Error |
± 3.26 |
± 0.42 |
±0.01 |
| (n1/N x 100)
survival rate at day 6 |
0%
(0/10) |
100%
(10/10) |
100%
(10/10) |
| (n2/N x 100)
mortality rate at day 6 |
100%
(10/10) |
0%
(0/10) |
0%
(0/10) |
A - Control (Infected but untreated)
B- Plasmogine 100 mg/kg/day
C- Chloroquine 20 mg/kg/day orally for 4 days
n- Number of mice survived at day 6
n- Number of mice died at day 6
N- Total number of mice inoculated with Plasmodium berghei
The highest
parasitaemia rates ( 44.24 ± 3.26% ) were recorded in control mice
(infected but untreated) with a mortality recorded in control
mice(infected but untreated) with a mortality rate of 100% on 6 th
day after infection. The oral Plasmogine (100 mg/kg/day
for 4 days) was found to be effective for rodent malaria. There was no
mortality in the group of mice receiving oral chloroquine (20mg/kg/day
for 4 days ).
Both the test (
suppressive and therapeutic ) showed the effectiveness of Plasmogine
in ddy mice infected with Plasmodium berghei. The
effective dosage was observed to be 100mg/kg/day for 4 days.
The in vitro
sensitivity assay with two isolates of Plasmodium falciparum was
shown in Table 1. The in vitro schizont inhibition was recorded
after 24-hr exposure to Plasmogine at the concentrations of 25,
50, 100, and 200 ΅g/ml. The In vitro schizont inhibition was
marked at the concentration of 50 ΅g/ml with the average inhibition rate
(mean of three experiments with two isolates of Plasmodium falciparum)
of 95%.
Table 2.
Mean schizont inhibition rates of Plasmodium falciparum after
24-hr exposure to Plasmogine in vitro.
Plasmogine
Concentration (΅g/ml) |
Schizont Inhibition Rates (%) |
MeanInhibition
Rate (%)
|
| |
P.
falciparum Isolate 1 |
P.
falciparum Isolate 2 |
|
| 0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
| 25 |
33.4 |
36.8 |
35.2 |
| 50 |
95.4 |
96.2 |
95.8 |
| 100 |
98.6 |
99.2 |
98.9 |
| 200 |
98.2 |
99.0 |
98.6 |
DISCUSSION
Sodium artesunate displayed
potent blood schizontocidal activity against the asexual forms of
P.falciparum at erythrocytic stage in cultures as well as against
P. berghei in mice and P .knowlesi in monkeys. The use of
subcutaneous or intravenous route of administration will not alter the
effect of artesunate on the parasites. The parasite clearance time was
shorter than all other antimalarials currenty in use. Comparative
treatment with sodium artesunate and quinine dihydrochloride, both given
intravenously to P. knowlesi infected rhesus monkeys, indicated
that the former was significantly better even at a dosage equivalent to
one-tenth of the later. Thus, time required for 90% parasite
clearance by sodium artesunate at 3.16mg/kg was only 13.2 hours,
whilst by quinine dihydrochloride at 31.6 mg/kg was 50.5hours. In our
study it was observed that the potency of the drug as evaluated against P.
falciparum in cultures was also higher than that of chloroquine and
quinine.
In the early 1940s, Jang and his
colleagues identified the structure of dichroine and found it to be
effective against chicken malaria. Clinical trial using the water-based
extract of Yin-pyar to treat patients suffering from P. falciparum
or P. vivax showed a significant effective rate. The total
alkaloids of Yin-pyar are 26-50 times more potent than quinine in
antimalarial activity. Among them, gamma--dichroine is the most
effective, being about 100 times more potent than quinine, - beta-dichroine
is the next most potent. The LD50 of the total alkaloids in
mice is 7.8 mg/kg (oral); the LD50 of , - beta-dichroine is
6.6 mg/kg.
Berberine (an alkaloid of Coptis
teeta) and 50% water-soluble alcoholic extract of rhizome of
Coptis teeta have been reported to be amoebicidal and
trichomonadocidal by some workers from Myanmar.
According to the WHO Guidelines on
combination therapy,FAME Pharmaceuticals Enterprise has initiated to
produce an antimalarial herbal drug using the total alkaloids extracted
from three reputed medicinal plants which process antimalarial activity
as well as antiprotozoal activity. Therefore, FAME has designated the
combined extracts of total alkaloids from three reputed medicinal plants
Dichroa febrifuga, Artemisia annua and Coptis teeta
and registered as Plasmogine.
In our study with Plasmogine,
the effective dose was observed to be 100mg/kg /day for four days. No
sign of toxicity were observed with Plasmogine even at the dosage
of 1600mg/kg/day for four days. The in vitro drug sensitivity
assays with P.falciparum also revealed the effectiveness of
Plasmogine with the minimum schizont inhibition of 50 ΅g/ml.
CONCLUSION
The efficacy of Plasmogine on
human malaria parasites (with special emphasis on
P.falciparum and P.vivax infected subjects) will be carried
out in near future. The Myanmar National Ethical Committee on testing of
new drug is now undertaking all the necessary measures to approve the
clinical trials of Plasmogine on human subjects.
|